Home » Adventures » Food » Columbia 1905 Restaurant Clearwater Beach Florida – Review
Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Sangria

Columbia 1905 Restaurant Clearwater Beach Florida – Review

by Mary Chong
This article may contain affiliate links. This means that clicking on or purchasing products we recommend through a link may earn us a small commission. For more information read our disclaimer page.

Share this article with your friends!

With generations of family photos lining the walls of the restaurant, dining at Columbia 1905 Restaurant in Clearwater Beach, Florida is like a step into one families history. It’s steeped in tradition with recipes of the Gonzmart family handed down from great-grandmother to grandmother, to mother to daughter.

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Family

The restaurant isn’t Columbian as what might have been expected with a name like Columbia 1905 but serves old world favourites that are actually Cuban Spanish.

At Columbia 1905 Restaurant the Cuisine Tastes like Tradition, Family and Home

Why “Columbia” then?

“Columbia” as Joe the Manager of the Clearwater Beach location on Sand Key explained, “was the name of the ship that the founder Casimiro Hernandez, Sr. sailed upon when he first immigrated in the late 1800’s”.

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Interior

Joe explained further that in 1905 the original Ybor City 60-seat corner café first opened to serve Cuban coffee and Cuban sandwiches to feed the Cuban families that immigrated to Tampa to work in the surrounding cigar factories. As time passed, the demand for the “flavours of home” grew, space next to the café became available, and the restaurant expanded further.

Today that same original Ybor City restaurant takes up the entire city block and seats 1,700 people in 15 dining rooms adding up to 52,000 square feet. Columbia 1905 is said to be the oldest restaurant in Florida, the largest Spanish restaurant in the world. To this day it is still family owned and operated.

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Interior

There are 7 locations to be found throughout South Florida – Ybor City, Clearwater Beach (as photographed here), Sarasota, Celebration, Riverwalk Tampa, St. Augustine and Tampa International Airport.

Save up to 51% or more on Tampa Bay’s 5 best attractions at CityPASS.com - Shop Now! 

What we ate at Columbia 1905 Restaurant

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Mojito

As our Cuban bread was warming in the oven, we started our evening with Mojitos. Both the bread and the drinks were very yummy. A unique feature is that many of their drinks, i.e., Mojito, Sangria, etc. may be ordered by the pitcher versus the single glass.

Original 1905 Salad

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Salad

No trip to this famous restaurant is complete without tasting the original 1905 Salad. The signature salad inspired by the many immigrants to Ybor City. Iceberg lettuce with Romano cheese, Swiss cheese, baked ham, tomato and olives tossed tableside with garlic dressing and Worcestershire sauce.

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Table side Salad

It sort of reminded me of a Caesar salad – it’s quite famous and has been profiled on many tv shows. The signature 1905 salad dressing is for sale in their gift shop.

Devil Crab Croquettes

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Croquettes

Blue crab, Cuban cracker crumbs with paprika, onions and garlic made using a traditional recipe by great-grandmother Aurora Gonzalez. Another signature Tapas selection this very tasty croquette had a bit of a kick to it.

Scallops “Casimiro”

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Scallops

Fresh scallops baked in a clay casserole with lemon butter and topped with seasoned breadcrumbs and white wine — perfectly cooked and very satisfying. Hubby Ray had a big smile on his face after his first bite of the scallop!

Delmonico “Sarapico”

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Delmonico

16 oz. bone-in char-grilled rib-eye steak served with roasted potatoes and vegetables. Columbia 1905 has their own butcher on staff and they definitely know how to cook a steak. It was a perfect medium-rare as was requested.

Costillas de Cordero

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Lamb Chops

Baby Lamb T-bones seasoned and grilled. Served with oven roasted potatoes, sautéed spinach and mint aioli.

Key Lime Pie

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Key Lime Pie

Created with a secret graham cracker crust recipe and a filing made with pasteurised egg yolks, condensed milk and lime juice; there are no preservatives, artificial ingredients or gelatin. In my mind that adds up to zero calories! Light, refreshing and not overly sweet or tart.

Check out this recipe: Key West Key Lime Pie

Save up to 51% or more on Tampa Bay’s 5 best attractions at CityPASS.com - Shop Now! 

Fresh Strawberries on Almond Cake

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Strawberry Almond Cake

Fresh Florida strawberries with sherry zabaione on homemade almond cake topped with whip cream.

Don’t forget to have a look at the lovely gift shop near the entrance for cigars, cookbooks, bottled versions of the salad dressing, seasonings, sauces, sangria mix, kitchen accessories and signature pottery.

Columbia 1905 Restaurant - Gift Shop

With indoor seating as well as an outdoor patio in the back overlooking the water, the Clearwater Beach Sand Key location is lovely. The atmosphere, service and cuisine throughout the night were simply wonderful. I look forward to dining here again and especially would like to visit the Ybor City location to see where all the magic first started.

Columbia 1905 Restaurant Clearwater Beach Florida - Review by Calculated Traveller

Columbia 1905

1241 Gulf Boulevard
Clearwater, FL 33767

More reviews are available on TripAdvisor.

Have you dined at a Cuban Spanish restaurant before? We’d love to hear what you ate and what you thought of the cuisine

Additional articles about Clearwater:
Clearwater Beach Marriott Suites on Sand Key – Review
Dining at Caretta on The Gulf, Clearwater Florida
Visions and Dreams at The Dali Museum in St. Petersburg Florida

Travel assistance provided by Visit St. Petersburg Clearwater Tourism. As always, the opinions expressed in this post are my own.

Looking for tours in the Clearwater area?

Share this article with your friends!

2 comments

Cristina ✈ (@travelingjourno) January 9, 2015 - 12:50 am

I’m a big fan of seafood + Cuban culture so all this looks delicious! Did you try a Cuba Libre? It’s their (very tasty) version of rum and coke.

Reply
Mary Chong January 16, 2015 - 10:30 pm

Didn’t try that drink – i’m not a fan of coke, but we did have traditional Cuban pastries….yummy!

Reply

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More